sign up log in
Want to go ad-free? Find out how, here.

Financial Markets Authority warns 'phony' interest rates comparison site likely harvesting information for fake investments

Business / news
Financial Markets Authority warns 'phony' interest rates comparison site likely harvesting information for fake investments

A “phony” interest rates comparison website may have been a front for harvesting New Zealanders’ personal details, the financial regulator says.

The Financial Markets Authority (FMA) warned on Friday that it believed the website “Compare Fixed Term Deposits” was collecting information to be used by criminals to sell fake investments.

The site claimed to offer consumers comparisons of all registered and regulated fixed-income investments in NZ, and find the highest rates, the FMA said in a press release.

But the website did not contain any comparison information, rather asking users to fill out a form with their personal details so a third party could contact them.

It urged consumers to “exercise extreme caution” with the site.

The regulator said it was encouraging people to come forward "with any similar experience".

FMA response and enforcement executive director Paul Gregory said the FMA strongly encouraged New Zealanders to only deal with locally-registered entities.

He said if someone was pushing consumers into an investment opportunity, people needed to step back and ask themselves why they were being offered the deal, whether it was legitimate, and not to be rushed into investing.

“Hit the pause button before sending or committing any of your money to people you cannot truly verify. Most often with scams like these, your money is transferred overseas and it is incredibly difficult for New Zealand authorities to get back.”

The FMA said it had received 154 complaints about investment scams and fraud and issued 40 public warnings about scams "and other non-compliant entities" from January to June 2023.

It said comparison sites were often presented in search results when people were searching for investment opportunities. 

Phony sites would often be presented alongside legitimate comparison sites and appear because they are paid for, sponsored links, rather than genuine search results, it said.

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment.

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.

15 Comments

Best to just login to your actual banking website and look at the rates. TD's can all be done online at the ASB, no need to even speak to anyone. Never been able to get a better rate than those listed so just do it all myself in a few minutes when it rolls over.

Up
2

You never look for better rates than your own bank Zwifter? ASB has been notoriously bad with rates...

Up
0

? Don't agree, they match all the other top banks every time I check. If you want to go with someone else other than the top 4 then sure you can squeeze a little more but that's the whole point of this article, stick with the major banks.

Up
0

Actually the point of this article is to avoid Phony sites . nothing to do with bank rates

Up
3

People end up on phony sites searching for rates stupidly. Just use interest.co.nz or go onto bank websites direct... don't stop shopping around though.

Up
0

Good advice Zwifter. Stick with what has always been trustworthy.

Up
0

ASB AA-Savings Plus - potential rate, no withdraw/qtr shows 5% in this rate page.

https://www.interest.co.nz/saving/bonus-savings-accounts

I don' t see it on  ASB site?

 

Up
0

Looks like 4.65% to me for combined base and full reward interest.

https://www.asb.co.nz/bank-accounts/savings-plus.html

Up
0

Even better, it's all right here in front of you. 

https://www.interest.co.nz/saving/term-deposits-1-to-5-years

Up
7

Exactly!

Up
1

Dear FMA

Please stop telling me to exercise caution and, like all of our banks, unfairly expecting me to carry the entire burden of security.

For the love of god you have evidence it is phony and used by criminals....what more do you need to shut it down.

This story should read, "Another win for the FMA, sham website shut down to protect our citizens".

Try harder.

Up
7

Absolutely agree hitch. FMA as usual, last to the party. Are they not onto these sites at the first whiff of trouble? As I understand it this fake Citibank process has been catching victims for months.

Up
4

You would think right? How about a fund setup that all financial institutions pay into and as soon as a scam is registered with DIA or FMA then anyone scammed by it gets paid from the fund.  Banks on the hook as the $ goes via their systems, and perhaps a $10 paid to everyone that reports a scam?  Perhaps the organisation the scam is purported to be from should pay any loses incurred from such a scam...looking at you citibank, NZTA, nz post, IRD....and the list goes on...they have the resources to do something about it...its time for carrots and VERY big sticks

Up
1

Good point Hitch22. Also, why don't the authorities catch these creeps with sting operations? It should be very easy. Catch them, shut them down, confiscate all their assets.

Up
1

I use interest.co.nz. If I have an existing deposit I open up the page that refers to this. If you have say 50K + deposit to roll over, they normally give you a small increase on top of the published rate, but they blow a bit hot and cold with this depending on how keen they are to keep your money. 

Up
0