The impact of new Reserve Bank limits on bank lending could force house rents in some areas up by as much as 50% in the next 12 to 18 months, according to property investor Olly Newland.
Newland, who's also an Authorised Financial Adviser and author, told interest.co.nz it was still too early to know what the effect of the so-called speed limits put on high loan-to-value lending (LVRs) by the RBNZ on October 1 would be.
It was possible the LVR limits "may well end up being a damp squib – nothing happens, business as usual".
If they bite...
"But if they do bite there will be quite serious repercussions and distortions…"
This could include rents, which have been relatively stagnant for many years while house prices have increased substantially, "bubbling up" as more people, unable to get into their own houses were forced to rent property.
"We may see headlines in 12 months from now that rents are too high," Newland said.
"If the LVR restrictions bite as we suggested, then I would think from now in the next 12 to 18 months rents could rise anywhere from 20% to 50% depending on what area you are talking about and of course depending on how deep the pockets are of the tenants - which of course means they can’t save as much to buy the house they are trying to buy."
First home buyers
Much of the focus of the impact of LVR limits is on how it may affect would-be first home buyers.
Asked what first home buyers should do and whether first-time buyers would miss out if they didn't buy know, Newland said: "You will miss out if you wait because prices generally over a period of time go up.
"There’s an old cartoon of a very old man bent over a stick with a caption saying this is the man who’s waiting for prices to come down."
Newland said he expected most young buyers would either borrow through second mortgages or get "mum and dad" to give them loans.
Unitary Plan
The Auckland Council this week formally notified the Auckland Unitary Plan, the new rulebook for the Auckland region that will decide what people can do with their land.
Newland said the new plan would provide opportunities.
"In essence the unitary plan allows for denser housing in a given area. So, again it will help investors, mums and dads too I guess, because property prices will tend to go up a lot in areas which have been rezoned for higher density.
Buy on main roads
"So if I was an investor and wanted to take advantage of the unitary plan I would be buying on the main roads for instance where there is transport and shops and schools and so forth and I think all the main road areas, or very close to the main road areas will, if they get the right zoning, will shoot up in value.
"Obviously, if one house on a section is worth x dollars, if you can suddenly put eight houses on that same section that’s going to be worth much, much more. So, I think it will have a big effect on property prices in certain areas."
Price rises continue
In terms of what might happen to house price in general over the next 12 to 18 months, Newland said if there was no outside event that affected house prices and the economy in general then house prices would continue to rise.
"Perhaps they will slow down a little bit but as a percentage of the whole it will still be a lot of money. Every few percent adds many many thousands and I suspect the rise will continue over the next 12 or 18 months perhaps at a slower rate but still a substantial amount of money involved.
"...And there will be a point reached when it is just too expensive and they’ll start to flatten down. And its probably a good thing.
...But not through the roof
"We don’t really want prices to go through the roof. It’s bad all around. We want gentle inflation and prices - 3% or 4% or 5% a year. That’s the way the capitalist system works.
"We don’t want a huge drop in prices because half of New Zealand would be in the street at that point being upside down with their mortgages.
"So that’s where I think things will go. But of course this LVR thing and anything else that comes along – perhaps a capital gains tax, who knows - will have another effect on the market."
16 Comments
@Basil BrushIII , dont disregard what he is saying in such an off-handed manner.
In addition to the points Olly has raised he has ignored one important one we often overlook
Every 24 hours we have about 250 skilled and/or monied migrants arriving in NZ from China , India, Phillipines and South Africa and note thats EVERY 24 HOURS , and we dont have enough accomodation to house them right now...... and they keep coming,
EVERY 24 HOURS they arrive by the multiple planeload,
Thats 90,000 a year arriving here., and that implies around 22,500 accomodation units every year , just for migrants , ignoring Kiwi first timers , etc
Most migrants settle in Auckland, hence the problem .
Now , the RBNZ in their wisdom, through the LTVR , restrict the market ability to reach a fair market clearing price , so it will lead to more housing stock shortages as sellers who dont need to sell hold back .
The only thing that can happen is that rents go north , simply becuase these migrants have to live somewhere and are forced to pay our already astronomical rents .
Its little wonder we see about 800 to 1000 Chinese faces at Barfoot and Thompson mass-house -auctions.The migrants are fed up with these rental levels and are pooling their resources and/or borrowing at 3% in Hong Kong to buy a roof over their heads .
Now , the RBNZ in their wisdom, through the LTVR , restrict the market ability to reach a fair market clearing price , so it will lead to more housing stock shortages as sellers who dont need to sell hold back .
!0% down and the rest supplied by the bank's depositors is hardly a recipe to discover an affordable clearing price. Leverage at this level only leads to higher prices until it suddenly doesn't as the greater fools run out of resources necessary to service the cost of using other people's money.
Give it up Boatman, I've tried many times to explain the basic rule of supply and demand and it's effect on prices, it will fall on deaf ears. You'll just get the usual chorus of "ponzi scheme" and "the greater fool". They all act as if somewhere to live is a optional thing that will go out of fashion.
I'm starting to wonder if there is an orchestrated campaign against the the LVR's. Must just be the chorus desperate to keep the music going.
And really, if you cant afford a 20% deposit on a house, you cant afford the house.
All the comments I've read are just the clattering hooves on the floor from the stampede of the stupid.
Well, lets see if Olly is right and more importantly for the right reasons.
It will be interesting to watch if the LVR cools the housing market and if as the counter rents rise...
Now sure that is possible....
NB I dont see why it would take so long.
12months from now if Labour wins of course that could have a bigger impact.....
regards
Nice out clause Olly the spruker:
"if there was no outside event that affected house prices and the economy in general"
Yep prices can go down; which is possible given the need for LVR, world economy, looming interest rate rises, bias for property - inflated prices.
If rents shoot up then tenants can and will walk out.. So what happens then?
I admit that I haven't been paying much attention lately, but doesn't Olly always predict rent rises, no matter what? High humidity - rent rises! You'll be stuck forever and won't even own the letterbox, blah blah blah. Pollen in the air - rent rises! Robot invasion - rent rises! Sky turns orange and the earth rotates backwards - rent rises!
Speaking from my own perspective, we have been renting to be close to our kid's school but have been given notice by the landlord- who needs to move back in. Looking around at the price for rentals in the Wellington region there does seem to have been an increase in rent asking prices. Quantities of houses to choose from seem to be lower than I remember too. So we have gone out and put an offer on a place. Now wishing we'd bought a year ago....
We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment.
Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.