sign up log in
Want to go ad-free? Find out how, here.

Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala explains why cooperation and transparency are key to mitigating the Ukraine war's impact on supply and prices of food commodities

Public Policy / opinion
Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala explains why cooperation and transparency are key to mitigating the Ukraine war's impact on supply and prices of food commodities
Wheat harvesting

The war in Ukraine is causing immense, heart-wrenching human suffering. At the World Trade Organization, an institution based on the rule of law and established to help forge peace, we find the violence abhorrent to our fundamental principles. We echo United Nations Secretary-General António Guterres’s call for the bloodshed to stop, and we wish for a prompt and peaceful resolution of the conflict.

But even as we remain transfixed by the shocking and tragic images of Ukrainian cities under attack, and even as we commit to doing all we can individually and collectively to help Ukraine’s people, it is also becoming clear that the war’s economic and humanitarian repercussions will be felt far beyond Europe. We have a responsibility to mitigate these consequences proactively as well.

Even prior to the war, rising food and energy prices were straining household and government budgets in many smaller and poorer countries whose economies had also been among the slowest to recover from the COVID-19 pandemic. New price spikes triggered by the conflict in Eastern Europe now threaten to cause poverty and food insecurity to rise. In these circumstances, the role of the WTO and trade in general, particularly for countries that are net food importers, is of paramount importance in preventing hunger.

While Ukraine and Russia together account for a modest 2.2% of global goods trade, according to WTO estimates, this figure understates their significance in grain and energy markets, and as suppliers of fertilizer, minerals, and other inputs critical for a wide range of downstream production activities. In 2020, for example, the two countries supplied 24% of globally traded wheat, and 73% of sunflower oil.

Imports of such commodities are essential for basic food security in the many countries that lack the water, soil, and weather conditions to grow all the food they need. Over the past 30 years, Ukraine and Russia have become key sources of grain for countries including Mongolia, Sri Lanka, Lebanon, Egypt, Malawi, Namibia, and Tanzania. The World Food Programme, the UN agency that provides food aid to people affected by conflict and disasters in more than 80 countries, typically procures more than half of its wheat from Ukraine.

War-induced blockages of Ukrainian ports and the international sanctions imposed on Russia have sharply reduced the available global volume of wheat. Fears that Ukrainian farmers will be prevented from growing this year’s spring crop have compounded supply concerns, causing the price of wheat futures to rise 40% and reach record highs in the first week of March.

Surging energy and food prices have begun to elicit familiar policy responses, with several governments restricting exports of grains and other key foodstuffs in an effort to maintain domestic supplies and limit price increases. The rising number of complaints to the WTO from exporters in several member countries and jurisdictions underscores the extent of the problem. Such export controls can trigger a spiral of price increases and new restrictions. The World Bank estimates that 40% of the increase in global wheat prices during the last food-price crisis in 2010-11 resulted from governments’ attempts to insulate domestic markets.

But the world can mitigate these risks. Experience shows that international cooperation can help manage the knock-on effects of surging food prices. For a decade, sharing information about food supplies and stockpiles through the Agricultural Market Information System has enabled leading exporters and importers to prevent panics and keep markets functioning smoothly.

With the global trading system already struggling to cope with high transport costs and congested ports, closer coordination could help stabilize international markets for food, energy, and commodities, and minimize additional disruptions to supply chains. Importantly, the WTO’s monitoring and transparency function can help ensure that food and agriculture supply chains that are not directly affected by sanctions remain open and operate efficiently.

Better visibility regarding market disruption would also enable the international community to identify and mobilize financial and other assistance for poor countries badly affected by rising food prices. This is particularly urgent because, even before the Ukraine war, the post-pandemic economic recovery had been leaving much of the world behind. Growth in the poorest countries was furthest behind the pre-2020 trend, reflecting their weak fiscal capacity and inequitable access to COVID-19 vaccines.

As the world watches Ukraine’s unfolding tragedy, we must all urgently focus on how to support the Ukrainian people. And it is natural and appropriate that governments will concentrate on the disruption to their own economies. But we must also act now to ensure that some of the world’s poorest and most vulnerable people – far away from the conflict and absent from the headlines – do not become collateral damage.


Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala, Director-General of the World Trade Organization, is a former finance minister and foreign minister of Nigeria and a former managing director of the World Bank. Copyright: Project Syndicate, 2022, published here with permission.

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment.

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.

31 Comments

The world has a poor record in place here,   if past performance is any indicator of future success, plans should be in place for famine relief.

Up
0

Too late  -as usual- the global food crisis started a year or so ago with floods in the US midwest plus climate issues in Brazil and Canada and fuel/conflict in Argentina all being large grain suppliers although Russia had a good harvest but that may not be a saviour now they are at war with Ukraine which is unlikely to produce as much this season as previous. Widepread famine and social unrest on top of a looming recession/depression predicts a chaotic & violent global climate. So glad to be in a largely self sufficient country so far away from the rest of the world even though ruled/lead by a bunch of incompetent clowns.

Up
11

China's got issues with its harvests too (and further down the track soil depletion...)

Up
4

Rumpole (of the Baily)

So, you would prefer an authoritarian government (Russia, China, Trump) rather than a democracy? Our parliamentary terms are only three years long so plenty of opportunity to vote another party in.  

Have you forgotten that the present government was elected by a record majority vote?  So why did National lose the last election.... perhaps because their clowns must have been doubly incompetent?  And this has been borne out by the hilarious comedy we have all been treated to over the past couple of years as National stumbles and fumbles to settle on someone...anyone.....even half-capable of leading the country in challenging times.  Looking completely bereft,  they have desperately taken yet another punt, but I see more hysterically funny episodes in the offing.  On the evidence, National couldn't organize a picnic.

Up
3

Don't drink and post, that's my advice.

Up
3

A died-in-the-wool Mike Hosking fan?   Read all the aunty-Herald commentators religiously?  Yesterday's men? Prebble, Joyce? 

Up
3

Not a "bottom feeder" obviously.

Up
0

Unfortunately you can't print food, like you can money.  Such a bug shock to world food supplies will echo around and there is only so much food to go around given the increasing number of people. Famine relief for every poor country may be what is required, but may not actually be possible.

Up
0

The latest NATO estimates put Russian casualties at about a fifth of overall forces in the first month of this war as reported by the WSJ this morning. That's incredibly unsustainable and may soon become a military rout leading to imminent and total Russian defeat in the Ukraine.

Much as to say, incredibly, Ukrainian farmers may be able to get crops in the ground in the second half of this year after all!

Up
0

The second half of the year is too late.  The planting season for spring crops is April and May.  Wheat is planted in the autumn but that will be for next year's crop.  This year's wheat crop is already in the ground and does have potential to be harvested in July and August.
KeithW

Up
2

Hopefully.

Up
0

wheat can be planted in the autumn* but 66% of Ukraine wheat is spring planted.  The winter wheat is mostly in Odessa and along the black sea coast.

I checked because Ukraine sounds like a frozen wasteland in the winter and I was surprised they could grow anything during winter.

Up
1

My understanding is that about 97% of Ukrainian wheat fields are sown in the autumn. Most of this as you say is in south eastern Ukraine. Last autumn about 6.5 million hectares were planted. A covering of snow helps the survival. I think that perhaps the 66% spring sown you refer to relates to other crops, and this is the the overall balance between winter and spring plantings.  In any case, any spring sown wheat would have to be going in by now.   It seems that the Russians are focusing on the cities and that farmers may still be able to plant crops (e.g. barley, corn  sunflowers) in many parts of the country as long as they have inputs at hand. The next few weeks will be crucial.
KeithW 

Up
1

I saw an article on Reuters stating that the exceptionally cold spring weather would likely have delayed field work anyway.

Up
0

Any news of Afghanistan which nz  helped usa crush . 

Up
2

Only took the US 20 years to liberate afghanistan, apparently it's wonderful there now, poppy fields and mine fields.

Up
0

Many have said that war is not good for the world. Yet how many heads of nations have called up Vlad P and urged him to stop the war.

Ukrainians appear to want a ceasefire.

I won't blame the Ukrainians for fighting, for their lives, for their country.

 

Up
1

Why doesn't somebody tell Putin what to do, or where to go? Surely the price on his head is worth the risks. The Russian people are paying heavily & will be paying heavily for this war for a long time.

Up
3

Always did wonder why some of the leaders like Putin and Assad were not just taken out in a Drone strike, I mean its not like it has not been done before on Iranians. Perhaps the risk of blowback is to big or just another head grows on the same snake anyway so what's the point ?

Up
4

During the second world war the British developed a plan to kill Hitler at his mountain retreat. They never ended up doing it though, reasoning that Hitler was so irrational that his likely successor would be more competent and tactically astute. NATO might reason President Putins military adventurism is weakening his military to the point where his conventional forces pose little threat.

Up
1

I think it's a bit simpler than that. If they target leaders then all leaders become fair game including and especially themselves.

 

Up
1

It seems Zelenski is coming out smelling of roses while parts of his country are being obliterated. Pity he cocked a snook at Russia for the last two years no doubt thinking this would not lead to something more serious. Zelensky and his cabinet relying on the West  (particularly NATO,EU and the USA) too much with the West not really give a hoot about Ukraine. Publicly it's another story. Now the war for both Russia and Ukraine is a disaster. Of course it's having world wide repercussions. Food shortages so what. Only the poor countries and the 3rd world will suffer. Most 1st world countries will hobble along for a few years and make suitable noises tut tutting here and there.

Governments are not elected on foreign policy. When history is written about 75-100 years down the line it won't be pretty for Zelensky and his cabinet or for anyone in the West for that matter.

 

Up
1

Yes, they poked the bear, but the bear overreacted.

Up
0

I wonder how Australia's crops are faring, with a lot more rain than normal?

Up
0

The key crop for Australia which varies hugely depending on weather conditions is the winter wheat crop which will be planted in coming months and harvested early summer. La Nina years typically bring the necessary winter rains so the outlook is good but nothing is certain at this point. The recent large rain events seem to have been mainly coastal. Inland there has been rain but nothing exceptional from what I can see.
KeithW

Up
0

Countries need to get off the wheat habit. A shipment of wheat does more damage to people than a Kalibr barrage.

Up
1

Don’t despair Zac,

Our local grocery store is stocking an impressive range of meat alternatives such as Tofu, both fresh and  in ready meals, surely they are selling as they take up valuable shelf space.

Also noteable are delicious vegetarian options by a very old NZ brand..Mary’s I think it’s called.

My bet would be the social networks are changing our views on diet..phewww…

 

Up
0

I'm by no means in despair. New Zealand is a great country to live with its ample supplies of grass fed beef and lamb, free farmed pork and eggs. Cheese is good too. Mince with 20% fat is cheap this week at Countdown.

Are you sure all that estrogen in the tofu and "meat alternatives" is not clouding your thinking? Stick with the poison I guess but you should note that our health system is a shambles. Best to keep away from it by eating mostly nutritious and non-poisonous meat is my advice. Eating four scrambled eggs cooked in butter as I type this and drinking coffee with full cream.

 

 

Up
1

It’s been thirty years since I ate Tofu but someone is, it has a big presence, things are changing.

Up
0

Changing for the worse? Good to hear, about not eating the tofu. Maybe its more noticeable because it sits on the shelves? During a recent meat shortage at my local I noticed it sitting there, in the meat section,  unbought.

Up
0

Now the issue about the climate change and the arrest of scientists that announced it. I wonder where will this take us.

 

https://www.electriciansouthauckland.kiwi/papakura/

Up
0