sign up log in
Want to go ad-free? Find out how, here.

Housing stock for sale, a big overhang of unsold properties and lacklustre sales are weighing on the housing market as it heads into spring

Property / analysis
Housing stock for sale, a big overhang of unsold properties and lacklustre sales are weighing on the housing market as it heads into spring
houses

 

The New Zealand housing market looks to be in an increasingly precarious position as it heads into spring.

Both the stock of properties for sale and the overhang of unsold properties is up compared to this time last year, while the number of properties dropping out of the market remains elevated for the time of year. Meanwhile the number of sales is down significantly on a year ago.

Property website Realestate.co.nz had a total of 32,908 residential properties available for sale at the end of August. That was up almost 10% on the same time last year, and was the most properties the website has had for sale at the end of August in 12 years.

Contributing to the high stock level was the large overhang of unsold properties.

The overhang is the number of properties that remain unsold after being on the market for more than a month.

Interest.co.nz estimates there was an overhang of around 24,600 residential properties at the end of August, up 16% compared to August last year. The overhang has not been that high at the end of August since 2014.

On top of that the number of dropouts remains high.

Dropouts are properties that have either been taken off the market completely, or are still listed for sale but are no longer being actively marketed, with no open homes or promotional activity.

Anecdotally, the main reason for dropouts is that their owners generally have unrealistic price expectations and refuse to meet the market, so their properties languish at the end of their marketing campaigns.

Interest.co.nz estimates there were around 3200 dropouts in August, up 4% from July.

It says something about the state of the market, and the unrealistic price expectations of many vendors, that the estimated number of dropouts has increased by 57% since 2023.

Whether they are rising or falling, the size of the overhang and the number of dropouts generally follow a seasonal pattern, peaking at the end of the summer season around May, then declining over the winter months before starting to pick up again in spring.

The worrying trend this year is that total stock for sale, the overhang and the number of dropouts are already at very high levels before the spring bounce kicks in, while sales numbers have headed south.

That could mean that the market moves even further in buyers' favour over the next few months as rising mortgage interest rates, uncertainty over potential tax changes for property investors and a lacklustre economic outlook all help to pile on the pressure on property sales and prices.

Summer might be just around the corner, but for the property market it may not be a summer of love.


We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.

10 Comments

Still no clearance 

Up
6

Agreed. Immigration staying low, cost of debt moving ever up towards normal levels, rents remain anti ponzi, and the only sellers are those accepting market reality aka capitulation. Add to all that is the impending US Treasury debt renewal falling due before the end of the year which will set a baseline for global debt. This "maturity wall" and estimated at somewhere between $7.5-10 Billion USD, looking to role from sub 1% to around 5%. So.... either a rabbit is yanked out of an Orange hat, or the global basement for returns on debt moves towards 5% 

#ponzi-explosive

Up
6

Somewhat ironically, if you can afford the elevated interest rates, a hard asset like property is one of the best wealth preserving defenses against the rampant inflation we're currently experiencing

Up
3

Agreed 100%. The crux is paying a sensible price and not being over exposed on excessive debt. The opposite of ponzi seminar investment models.

Up
4

This is the key entry price and debt. Two 675sqm Sunnynook sites tell the story. One bought Feb 2020 for $1.05m, the other Nov 2021 for $1.95m. Current RVs $1.35m and $1.5m, with both land values at $1.2m.

Same underlying land value, but a $900k difference in what was paid just 21 months apart. Property can work long term, but price and leverage matter enormously.

Up
1

It really depends as Averageman says. If the cost of debt rises much faster than the cash flows associated to the asset (ie wages/rents) then the present value of those cash flows get smashed. So it’s ability to be a defence against inflation could actually turn out to be very poor.

This can be seen in things like Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) of bonds - that represent that inflation vs cash flow dynamics in real time (as they immediately update to movements in both aspects to reprice the present value of those cash flows).

See what has happened to the likes of the TLT (a highly traded US 20y treasury bond fund). It’s down like 60% and still dropping as inflation and interest rates rise over the past 5 years. 

https://www.marketwatch.com/investing/fund/tlt

I think in real terms (ie how well something like housing performs relative to inflation), something similar could well happen to housing here over the coming years - but the repricing just isn’t as dynamic as a highly traded bond fund like the TLT. So it will show up over the next few years. I think we are about halfway through that repricing now and by 2030 will have a much clearer picture. 

Up
4

Another day, another property market hit piece. 

Up
2

There’s a pretty good chance there will be another 5 years or more of hit pieces to come. 

Rockstar economy has transitioned to making hits…on the housing market.

Up
5

The great thing about the truth.... is it is the truth. If you have a problem with it, its clearly your problem.

Up
9

I hear the same BS from Mike Hosking every morning, try to flog a dead house

Up
0